Get $20 off a brand and website audit with the code AUDIT20 at checkout:
https://shop.wickydesign.com/product/brand-website-audit/
Chapters:
- 0:00 Intro
- 1:29 Pro Tips
- 3:50 My Self Help Story
- 5:23 The Self Help Promise
- 10:34 Are these people qualified?
- 12:57 Is this a cult?
- 18:09 Do we even need this?
- 20:08 What do we need?
- 21:41 Something to consider
The Self-Help Industry Is Making You Feel Like You’re Not Good Enough
The self-help industry has become a massive business. There are books and online courses promising to improve every part of your life. There are motivational speakers filling stadiums and people charging thousands of dollars for workshops that supposedly teach you how to become a better version of yourself.
Apparently we’re all doing something wrong. We’re not productive enough or disciplined enough. We’re not making enough money and we’re not taking enough risks. Our relationships need improvement and our morning routines aren’t good enough. According to the people selling these programs there’s always something about our lives that needs to be fixed.
But don’t worry because someone has the answer. For the right price they’ll teach you how to change your mindset and reach your full potential.
I’ve spent enough time in the self-help world to start questioning whether any of this is actually helping people. I’m not against personal development and I certainly don’t think there’s anything wrong with wanting to improve your life. But there’s a difference between learning something useful and constantly being convinced that you’re not good enough as you are.
The more I look at how the self-help industry operates, the more I wonder whether some of these programs are designed to help people improve or simply keep them coming back for more.
Offering More Choices Isn’t Always Better for Your Business
Before getting into my experience with self-help I want to share something that applies to almost every business. Offering customers more choices doesn’t necessarily make your business better. Sometimes having too many options makes the entire experience more complicated.
I’ve seen businesses offer endless variations of their products because they believe customers want as many choices as possible. Designers might present several different concepts for a project while service-based businesses create complicated packages with numerous options and upgrades.
The problem is that too many choices can make it difficult for customers to make a decision. Instead of feeling like they have more freedom they become overwhelmed and start second-guessing themselves.
I’ve experienced this with design projects. When you present several different concepts to a client, the discussion can turn into combining pieces from each option. They like the colors from one design and the layout from another. Then they want the typography from a third concept. Before long you’ve combined several ideas into something that isn’t nearly as strong as the original designs.
The same thing can happen with service packages. Customers might select the least expensive option but still expect some of the benefits included in the higher-priced packages. Instead of making your services easier to purchase you’ve created more opportunities for confusion.
Restaurants are another good example. When a restaurant has an enormous menu it needs to purchase and manage ingredients for all those different dishes. That creates additional expenses and makes operations more complicated.
Sometimes simplifying what you offer is the smartest decision you can make. Customers don’t always need dozens of options. They need enough information to make a good decision and some direction from a business that understands what it’s selling.
When customers know what to expect it becomes easier for them to move forward. It also makes your business easier to manage because you’re not constantly creating different versions of everything you offer.
How I Got Caught Up in the Self-Help Industry
A few years ago I was going through a period where I felt overwhelmed by different parts of my life. I was trying to figure out how to run our business without exhausting myself. I wanted to sleep better and develop healthier habits. I was also thinking about how to become more disciplined and improve my relationships.
It felt like there were a hundred different things I should be doing better and I wasn’t particularly satisfied with how I was handling any of them.
That’s when I started consuming a lot of self-help content.
I bought books and listened to podcasts. I followed motivational speakers and watched videos from people who seemed to have everything figured out. They were confident and financially successful. They talked about their routines and the decisions they’d made that supposedly changed their lives.
From where I was sitting these people seemed to have answers to questions I’d been struggling with for years.
So I started following their advice. I read about productivity techniques and tried different methods for improving my daily routine. I consumed more content because I genuinely believed that eventually something would click and I’d experience the same kind of personal transformation everyone was talking about.
But that never really happened.
I didn’t suddenly become a completely different person. I wasn’t dramatically more focused or productive. I was still dealing with the same responsibilities and challenges I’d been dealing with before.
Eventually I started wondering whether I was doing something wrong. Maybe I wasn’t committed enough or hadn’t followed the instructions properly. Perhaps everyone else was getting these incredible results and I was the one person who couldn’t figure it out.
That experience made me question something I’d never really considered before. What if the problem wasn’t that I needed to work harder at improving myself? What if the industry I’d been turning to for advice was making me feel worse about my life?
The Self-Help Industry Sells the Promise of a Better Life
One of the things I’ve noticed about self-help marketing is that the product itself is rarely the most important part of the sales pitch. What they’re really selling is the possibility of becoming a completely different person.
They’re selling confidence and financial freedom. They’re selling better relationships and the belief that you can accomplish anything if you follow the right system.
That’s a pretty attractive offer when you’re feeling overwhelmed or dissatisfied with your life.
But there’s something about that message that bothers me. It often begins by convincing you that your current situation isn’t good enough.
You’re told that you’re falling behind or wasting your potential. Maybe you’re not ambitious enough or you’re allowing bad habits to prevent you from becoming successful. Whatever the problem might be there’s supposedly something holding you back.
And conveniently the person explaining all these problems also happens to have something they can sell you to fix them.
Maybe it’s a book or an online course. It could be a coaching program or an expensive weekend seminar. Whatever they’re offering is presented as the thing that’s going to help you finally make the changes you’ve been struggling to accomplish.
The problem is that there’s rarely a point when you’re encouraged to stop.
Once you’ve completed one program there’s usually another one waiting. You’ve improved your productivity but now you need to work on your mindset. You’ve changed your morning routine but apparently you haven’t reached your full potential yet.
There’s always something else you should be doing.
When I think back to how much self-help content I consumed, I realize I spent a lot of time searching for answers to problems that weren’t necessarily as serious as I’d convinced myself they were.
Instead of appreciating the things that were going well in my life I was constantly looking for something that needed improvement.
How Self-Help Programs Keep Customers Coming Back
One of the most effective things about the self-help business model is how easily it can turn occasional customers into people who continue purchasing additional products.
Someone might discover a motivational speaker through a free video or podcast. They enjoy the content and decide to purchase a book. Eventually they’re encouraged to sign up for a more expensive course because that’s where they’re told they’ll receive additional guidance.
Once they’ve completed that course there might be an advanced program or an exclusive membership available.
Each purchase makes the person feel like they’re getting closer to accomplishing something important. But there’s rarely a clear endpoint where the customer is told that they’ve learned enough and don’t need to purchase anything else.
That’s what concerns me about some of these programs.
There’s nothing wrong with offering different levels of educational content. A person might genuinely benefit from taking an introductory course before moving on to more advanced material.
But when every product is marketed as the missing piece that will finally change someone’s life, I think it’s reasonable to question whether the business is interested in helping people become independent.
There’s also a lot of pressure created through limited availability and exclusive experiences. Customers are told that only a certain number of spaces are available or that they need to act immediately to avoid missing an opportunity.
That kind of marketing can encourage people to make expensive decisions without spending much time considering whether they actually need what’s being offered.
And if someone finishes a program without experiencing the results they expected, the explanation often focuses on their personal commitment.
They didn’t work hard enough or weren’t willing to make the necessary changes. Maybe they need another course to understand what they missed.
It’s an arrangement where customers can continue spending money while becoming increasingly convinced that they’re responsible for not achieving the results they were promised.
Tony Robbins and the Business of Personal Transformation
Tony Robbins is one of the most recognizable figures in the self-help industry and I think his business is an interesting example of how personal development can become an enormous commercial operation.
He’s written bestselling books and built a business around seminars and coaching programs. His events attract large audiences and use motivational music along with group participation and activities designed to create intense emotional experiences.
One of the better-known activities associated with his events is firewalking. The idea is to demonstrate that people can overcome fears or accomplish something they previously believed was impossible.
I can understand why someone might leave an event like that feeling motivated. Being surrounded by enthusiastic people and participating in activities that challenge your expectations can be exciting.
But feeling motivated at an event and making lasting changes in your everyday life are two very different things.
What interests me most is how the business is structured. Someone can begin by consuming free content and eventually purchase books or attend a seminar. From there they might consider more expensive experiences that offer additional access or personalized attention.
The most exclusive programs can cost thousands of dollars.
There’s a commercial reason for offering different levels of access but I think customers should question whether paying more is actually going to produce better results.
Another part of this approach is the emphasis on personal responsibility. People are encouraged to believe that they have the power to change their circumstances through their own decisions and actions.
There’s certainly value in taking responsibility for things you can control. But it becomes problematic when someone is made to feel that every unsuccessful outcome is evidence that they didn’t try hard enough.
Not everything in life is completely within our control and following someone’s advice doesn’t guarantee a particular result.
I think Tony Robbins is an extremely successful businessman. He’s built a recognizable brand and developed products that people continue purchasing. But I also think it’s worth separating the success of the person selling a program from the results customers can realistically expect to achieve.
Just because someone has become wealthy teaching personal development doesn’t automatically mean their methods will make everyone else successful.
What Actually Qualifies Someone to Give Self-Help Advice?
Something I think people should ask more often is what makes a particular self-help personality qualified to provide the advice they’re selling.
It’s one thing for someone to share their personal experiences. If a person has built a successful business and wants to explain how they did it, that information might be useful.
But there’s a difference between describing your own experiences and presenting yourself as an expert in psychology or mental health.
Some self-help personalities offer advice about relationships and emotional well-being without having professional qualifications in those areas. Others use scientific terminology to describe their programs even when they haven’t provided reliable evidence supporting their claims.
You’ll hear phrases about rewiring the brain or changing your entire mindset through a specific technique. Those descriptions can sound impressive but they don’t necessarily tell you whether the method has been properly studied or shown to produce the results being advertised.
I’m particularly skeptical when people use scientific language without explaining where their information comes from.
If someone claims a technique is supported by research then I think customers should be able to find that research and understand what it actually demonstrates.
Having a professional license or degree isn’t necessary to share every kind of useful advice. Plenty of experienced people have valuable things to teach. But credentials become much more important when someone is offering guidance that involves mental health or medical treatment.
A confident presentation and an impressive personal story aren’t substitutes for professional expertise.
Before spending money on a program I’d want to understand who created it and what experience they have. I’d also want to know whether the results being advertised have been independently supported or are simply based on a few customer testimonials.
There’s nothing wrong with asking those questions. If someone discourages you from questioning their methods then that alone would make me cautious about working with them.
When Self-Help Starts Looking Like a Cult
One of the more disturbing things I’ve noticed while learning about the self-help industry is how certain organizations have used personal development as a way to establish control over their members.
That doesn’t mean every self-help program is dangerous or that every motivational speaker is running a cult. Most people who purchase a self-improvement book aren’t going to end up in a harmful organization.
But there are documented examples of groups that initially attracted members through promises of personal growth before becoming deeply controlling.
What interests me is how these organizations begin.
People usually join because they’re looking for something positive. They might be struggling with a relationship or trying to improve their career. Some want a community of people who share similar interests while others are simply searching for a sense of direction.
At first the organization might seem welcoming and supportive. Members are encouraged to participate in activities and are told that they’re becoming part of something special.
But in more extreme cases the expectations gradually change.
Members might be pressured to spend more money or become increasingly dependent on the leader. Questioning the organization’s teachings can be discouraged and relationships outside the group might begin to suffer.
There are several well-known examples that demonstrate how serious these situations can become.
NXIVM: When Personal Development Became Exploitation
One of the most disturbing examples is NXIVM, the organization founded by Keith Raniere in 1998.
NXIVM initially presented itself as a personal development company offering programs intended to help people become more successful and overcome personal limitations.
The organization attracted people from different professional backgrounds and included some recognizable names. Actress Allison Mack and members of the Bronfman family were among those associated with the group.
Behind its public image the organization became involved in serious criminal activity. Prosecutors established that Raniere had used the group to exploit members through coercion and abuse.
Raniere was convicted of federal crimes including racketeering and sex trafficking. He was sentenced to 120 years in prison.
What makes this case particularly disturbing is that many participants originally joined because they believed the programs would improve their lives.
They weren’t necessarily looking to join an abusive organization. They believed they were participating in something that would help them develop personally or professionally.
The NXIVM case is an extreme example but it demonstrates what can happen when a leader’s authority goes unquestioned and members become increasingly dependent on an organization.
The Weigh Down Workshop and Remnant Fellowship
Another organization that has received considerable scrutiny is the Weigh Down Workshop founded by Gwen Shamblin Lara.
The program combined weight loss advice with religious teachings and became popular among people looking for a different approach to managing their eating habits.
Shamblin eventually founded Remnant Fellowship Church which developed a devoted following around her teachings.
The organization has faced allegations and criticism involving controlling behavior and harmful disciplinary practices. Former members have described experiences that raised concerns about the amount of influence church leaders exercised over their lives.
Shamblin had a background in nutrition but her organization’s teachings eventually extended well beyond that area. Religious authority and personal guidance became deeply connected within the group.
She died in a plane crash in 2021 and the church continued after her death.
What I find interesting about this situation is how something that began as a weight loss program developed into an organization that influenced so many different parts of its members’ lives.
It raises an important question about how easily people can begin relying on one individual for advice that extends far beyond that person’s original area of experience.
Twin Flames Universe and the Promise of Finding True Love
Twin Flames Universe is another example of an organization that has faced serious allegations about how it treats its members.
Founded by Jeff and Shaleia Divine, the group promotes the idea that everyone has a destined romantic partner known as a twin flame. Its programs offer guidance intended to help members find or connect with that person.
The concept can sound attractive to someone who’s struggling with relationships or feeling lonely.
But former members have described troubling experiences involving financial pressure and controlling behavior. Some have alleged that they were encouraged to cut ties with people outside the organization or pursue relationships that they weren’t comfortable with.
These allegations have been explored in documentaries and reporting about the group.
What concerns me about organizations like this is the way personal vulnerability can become an opportunity for someone else to claim authority over major life decisions.
People looking for companionship or guidance might begin trusting someone who claims to understand their future better than they do.
There’s a major difference between helping someone think through a relationship and telling them that an organization has the authority to determine who they should be with.
What These Organizations Can Teach Us About Questioning Authority
The organizations I’ve discussed are extreme examples and they shouldn’t be treated as representative of the entire self-help industry. There are plenty of people providing legitimate educational resources and useful personal guidance.
But I think these cases raise important questions about how much authority we’re willing to give someone simply because they appear confident or successful.
A person can have an enormous audience and still provide questionable advice. They might have an impressive business or an expensive lifestyle but that doesn’t necessarily mean they’re qualified to make decisions about someone else’s health or relationships.
I also think we need to pay attention to how organizations respond when people question their methods.
If you’re discouraged from thinking critically or told that questioning the program means you’re not committed enough, that’s a reason to be concerned.
If an organization pressures you to stop communicating with friends or family who disagree with its teachings, that’s an even more serious warning sign.
And if you’re constantly being told that the next expensive purchase is necessary before you can finally accomplish your goals, it’s worth asking whether that arrangement is actually benefiting you.
Useful advice should help people become more capable of making their own decisions. It shouldn’t require unquestioned loyalty or continued dependence on the person providing it.
Do We Really Need to Improve Every Part of Our Lives?
After spending time thinking about my own experience with self-help, I’ve started questioning whether we really need as much personal development content as we’re encouraged to consume.
There’s nothing wrong with wanting to improve yourself. I think learning new skills and developing healthier habits can be valuable. We should be open to recognizing areas where we could make positive changes.
But does every part of our lives really need constant improvement?
Apparently we’re supposed to wake up before sunrise and spend hours developing the perfect morning routine. We need to be more productive at work and turn every hobby into an additional source of income.
We’re encouraged to track our habits and constantly evaluate whether we’re making enough progress.
At some point I think we need to ask whether all this effort is actually making our lives better.
If you have a stable income and people you care about, perhaps your life is already going pretty well. Maybe you enjoy your work and have enough free time to pursue things that make you happy.
Of course there’s nothing wrong with wanting more. But having a perfectly ordinary life doesn’t automatically mean you’re missing something important.
I think the self-help industry has convinced some people that being satisfied with what they already have means they’re not ambitious enough.
And I don’t agree with that.
You can appreciate your current life without giving up on future goals. You can enjoy where you are without feeling like you need to become a completely different person.
There’s also something exhausting about constantly evaluating every decision and habit through the lens of personal improvement.
Sometimes you should be able to enjoy a hobby without thinking about how to make money from it. You should be able to take a day off without wondering whether you’re wasting an opportunity to become more productive.
Life shouldn’t feel like one enormous project that you’re never allowed to finish.
How to Tell the Difference Between Useful Advice and Expensive Promises
I don’t think the answer is to completely reject self-help. There are books and educational programs that contain useful information. Learning from other people’s experiences can help you recognize problems or approach situations differently.
Professional counseling can also be valuable for people dealing with emotional or mental health concerns. There’s a big difference between getting help from a licensed professional and following advice from someone who simply claims to have discovered the secret to happiness.
What matters is understanding why you’re looking for help and what you’re hoping to accomplish.
If you want to learn a specific skill then taking a course might make sense. If you’re struggling with something affecting your mental health then working with an appropriate professional could be beneficial.
But if you’re constantly purchasing self-help content because someone has convinced you that you’re failing at life, I’d question whether those purchases are helping.
Sometimes the thing you need isn’t another program or a complicated productivity system.
Maybe you’re exhausted because you haven’t been getting enough sleep. Perhaps you’ve been working too much and need to take some time away from your business.
You might benefit more from spending time with friends and family than listening to another podcast about becoming more successful.
I think it’s important to recognize the difference between wanting to learn something and feeling pressured to change who you are.
You Might Already Be Living the Best Years of Your Life
Something I’ve started thinking about more often is how easy it is to overlook the things that are going well in our lives.
We spend so much time concentrating on what we want next that we sometimes forget to appreciate what we already have.
Maybe you’re trying to earn more money or build a bigger business. Perhaps you’re saving for a different house or thinking about what you need to accomplish over the next few years.
There’s nothing wrong with having those goals. But have you ever considered that the life you’re living right now might be something you’ll look back on and miss?
You might have good relationships and a comfortable home. Maybe your health is good and you’re able to spend time doing things you enjoy.
From someone else’s perspective you might already have the kind of life they’re working toward.
But because you’re constantly thinking about what comes next, you don’t always recognize how good your current situation is.
I spent years doing exactly that.
I was always thinking about the next thing I needed to accomplish. I convinced myself that if I could improve certain habits or follow the right advice then everything would finally come together.
Eventually I started taking a more honest look at my life.
I realized that I already had so many things I’d spent years working toward. I had a home and a business that allowed me to do work I enjoyed. I was healthy and had a great relationship with my husband.
There were still things I wanted to accomplish but that didn’t mean my current life was somehow inadequate.
For a long time I’d been so focused on trying to improve everything that I wasn’t appreciating the life I’d already built.
That realization changed how I thought about self-help and personal development.
You Don’t Need Another Guru to Tell You How to Live
I think one of the biggest problems with the self-help industry is that it encourages people to believe there’s always another level they need to reach.
You accomplish one goal and immediately start working toward something bigger. You develop a healthy habit and begin looking for another routine to improve. There’s never really a point when someone tells you that you’ve done enough and should enjoy what you’ve accomplished. But I think it’s important to recognize that personal growth should be something you choose rather than something you’re constantly pressured to pursue.
You don’t need to wake up at 4:30 in the morning simply because a successful person claims that’s how they became wealthy. You don’t need to purchase an expensive workshop because someone told you that your current mindset is holding you back.
And you certainly don’t need to change every part of your personality to match someone else’s idea of a successful person.
If there’s something you’d genuinely like to improve then go ahead and work on it. Learn the skills you need and find resources that can help. But do it because you want to make that change and because it makes sense for your life. Don’t do it because someone convinced you that you’re falling behind or that you need another expensive program to become acceptable.
For me the most important lesson from my experience with self-help has been learning to appreciate what I already have. I still want to improve certain things and there are plenty of goals I’d like to accomplish. But I’m no longer interested in constantly searching for problems that need to be fixed.
Sometimes the best thing you can do is stop comparing your life to someone else’s version of success and recognize that you’re already doing pretty well.
You can want to improve your life without believing that your current life isn’t good enough.
And maybe that’s something worth remembering the next time someone tries to sell you a program that’s guaranteed to change everything.